A Deep Dive into $_REQUEST vs. $_POST vs. $_GET: Understanding Precedence and Pitfalls

Avoid using $_REQUEST due to unpredictable data source and security risks; 2. Use $_GET for idempotent operations like filtering, $_POST for state-changing actions like form submission; 3. The value in $_REQUEST depends on request_order in php.ini, leading to inconsistent behavior; 4. $_REQUEST includes data from $_GET, $_POST, and $_COOKIE, making it vulnerable to cookie manipulation; 5. Prefer explicit checks with $_GET or $_POST based on request method to ensure clarity and security; 6. Configure request_order in php.ini if necessary, but do not rely on $_REQUEST in production code; 7. Treat $_REQUEST as a legacy feature and use input validation libraries instead for robust input handling.

When working with PHP and handling form data or URL parameters, understanding the differences—and interactions—between $_REQUEST, $_POST, and $_GET is crucial for writing secure, predictable, and maintainable code. While all three superglobals are used to retrieve user input, they behave differently and come with their own nuances, especially when it comes to precedence and potential pitfalls.

Let’s break down each one and explore how they interact.

What Are $_GET, $_POST, and $_REQUEST?

• $_GET
  Contains data sent via the URL query string (e.g., ?name=john&age=25). It's typically used for non-sensitive, idempotent operations like filtering or pagination.

  

• $_POST
  Holds data sent in the body of an HTTP POST request, commonly from HTML forms with method="post". It's used for actions that change state (e.g., submitting a form, uploading data) and can handle larger or sensitive data.

• $_REQUEST
  A superglobal that, by default, combines data from $_GET, $_POST, and $_COOKIE. It’s a convenience array—but one that introduces ambiguity if not used carefully.

  

How $_REQUEST Works: Default Behavior and Precedence

By default, $_REQUEST aggregates input from:

• $_GET
• $_POST
• $_COOKIE

The order in which these sources are processed is determined by PHP’s variables_order and request_order directives in php.ini. But more importantly, the precedence depends on the order defined in request_order or variables_order.

For example, if request_order = "GP" (GET then POST), then:

• If both GET and POST contain a parameter named id, the GET value will overwrite the POST value in $_REQUEST.
• If request_order = "PG", POST takes precedence.

⚠️ This means: The value you get from $_REQUEST['key'] is not guaranteed—it depends on server configuration.

Example:

// URL: /page.php?user=admin
// POST data: user=guest

echo $_REQUEST['user']; // Could be 'admin' OR 'guest' depending on request_order!

This inconsistency is a major reason to avoid $_REQUEST in production code.

Common Pitfalls of Using $_REQUEST

1. Unpredictable Data Source
   You can’t be sure whether the value came from GET, POST, or a cookie. This makes debugging harder and increases the risk of logic errors.

2. Security Risks via Cookies
   Since $_REQUEST includes $_COOKIE by default, a user could potentially manipulate input by setting a malicious cookie with the same name as a form field.

   Example:

   // An attacker sets a cookie: admin=1
   // Meanwhile, your form sends POST: admin=0
   if ($_REQUEST['admin']) {
       grant_access(); // Oops! Cookie wins if request_order includes C and prioritizes it
   }

3. CSRF and Idempotency Confusion
   Using $_REQUEST might make you accidentally process GET requests as if they were POST (e.g., deleting a record via a GET link), opening the door to CSRF attacks or unintended actions.

4. Caching and Logging Side Effects
   GET parameters appear in logs and URLs, while POST data generally doesn’t. Mixing them via $_REQUEST can lead to sensitive data leaking into logs or browser history.

Best Practices: When to Use Which?

• ✅ Use $_GET for read-only, idempotent operations (search, filters, pagination).
• ✅ Use $_POST for actions that modify data or require security (login, form submission).
• ✅ Avoid $_REQUEST unless you have a very specific, controlled use case (e.g., shared utility functions in a tightly managed environment).

Instead of:

$username = $_REQUEST['username'];

Prefer:

if ($_SERVER['REQUEST_METHOD'] === 'POST') {
    $username = $_POST['username'] ?? null;
} else {
    $username = $_GET['username'] ?? null;
}

Or better yet, use a request abstraction layer or input validation library to handle this cleanly.

Can You Change $_REQUEST Behavior?

Yes—via php.ini:

# Determines which globals are created and merged into $_REQUEST
request_order = "GP"   ; GET then POST (common secure choice)
# request_order = "GP" means $_GET overrides $_POST in $_REQUEST
# To disable cookies in $_REQUEST:
variables_order = "EGP" ; Exclude 'C' for cookie

If you set:

request_order = "P"

Then $_REQUEST will only contain POST data—effectively making it an alias for $_POST. But this is non-standard and could break third-party code.

Bottom Line

While $_REQUEST seems convenient, its ambiguity and dependency on server configuration make it risky. The small amount of typing saved isn’t worth the potential bugs or security flaws.

Recommendations:

• Explicitly use $_GET or $_POST based on intent.
• Never use $_REQUEST for critical operations like authentication or data modification.
• Validate and sanitize input regardless of source.
• Treat $_REQUEST as a legacy feature—best avoided in modern applications.

Basically, if you're not sure why you need $_REQUEST, you probably don't.

The above is the detailed content of A Deep Dive into $_REQUEST vs. $_POST vs. $_GET: Understanding Precedence and Pitfalls. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!