Understanding Memory Management Differences: Golang's GC vs Python's Reference Counting

The core difference between Go and Python in memory management is the different garbage collection mechanisms. Go uses concurrent mark clearance (Mark and Sweep) GC, which automatically runs and executes concurrently with program logic, effectively deals with circular references. It is suitable for high concurrency scenarios, but cannot accurately control the recycling time; while Python mainly relies on reference counting, and object references are immediately released when zeroed. The advantage is that they are instant recycling and simple implementation, but there is a circular reference problem, so they need to use the gc module to assist in cleanup. In actual development, Go is more suitable for high-performance server programs, while Python is suitable for script classes or applications with low performance requirements.

The core of the difference between Go and Python in memory management is that their garbage collection mechanisms are different. Go uses a Mark and Sweep garbage collector, while Python mainly relies on reference counting and is supplemented by a loop detection mechanism. Understanding these differences will help us write more efficient and stable programs.

Go's garbage collection: automatic and efficient

Go uses a Concurrent Mark and Sweep GC. Its characteristics are:

• Automatic run : Developers do not need to manually release memory.
• Concurrent execution : GC and program logic run concurrently to reduce pause time.
• Based on root object scanning : Starting from global variables and variables on the stack, find all reachable objects, and the remaining unreachable objects will be recycled.

The advantage of this method is that it can effectively deal with circular reference problems and is also suitable for large-scale concurrency scenarios. But the downside is that there may be a short "Stop the World" phase (although Go's GC is now very well optimized), and in some extreme cases it may not be as good as reference counting to free memory in time.

In actual use, you hardly have to worry about memory release issues, but it also means you cannot control exactly when memory is recycled.

Python's reference count: instant but error-prone

Python uses the reference counting mechanism to manage memory by default. Each object has a reference counter. When this counter becomes 0, the memory occupied by the object will be immediately released.

The advantages are obvious:

• Instant release : Once it is no longer used, the memory is recycled immediately.
• Simple implementation : clear logic, easy to understand and debug.

But there are also obvious shortcomings:

• Unable to handle circular references : For example, two objects refer to each other, and even if they are no longer referenced from the outside, the reference count will not be zeroed.
• High performance overhead : Frequent increase and decrease reference counts will affect performance, especially in multi-threaded environments.

To solve this problem, Python also introduced the gc module to perform circular garbage detection, but it is not enabled by default and will cause additional delays.

Selection suggestions in actual development

If you are writing high-performance server programs, especially in scenarios where a large number of concurrency is required, Go's GC performs better, and it has taken into account the needs of modern servers from the beginning. Python is more suitable for script-like tasks or applications with less extreme performance requirements.

For example:

• Are you writing a highly concurrent network service? Go is the better choice.
• Are you doing data processing scripts or small tools? Python may be more convenient.

In addition, try to avoid creating complex object graph structures in Python, especially those involving circular references; in Go, you should pay attention to reasonably control the object life cycle and avoid unnecessary memory usage.

Summarize the key points

• Go's GC is a concurrent mark-clearing algorithm, suitable for high-concurrency and low-latency scenarios.
• Python's reference counting mechanism is simple and direct, but it is easy to cause circular reference problems.
• Both mechanisms have their own advantages and disadvantages, and there is no absolute good or bad, depending on the specific application scenario.
• If you choose between the two, in addition to the language ecosystem, you should also consider the performance impact of memory management.

Basically that's it.

The above is the detailed content of Understanding Memory Management Differences: Golang's GC vs Python's Reference Counting. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!