Fastest Way to List All Primes Below N: An Exploration
Problem:
Determine the fastest method to list all prime numbers less than a given integer N.
Question:
Can the given algorithm be optimized for faster execution?
Answer:
The provided algorithm can be significantly improved for speed. A comparison of various implementations reveals that rwh_primes1 with Psyco is the most efficient for generating primes less than 1,000,000.
Additional Findings:
- Without Psyco, rwh_primes2 emerges as the fastest method.
- Utilizing NumPy offers further performance enhancements, with primesfrom2to proving to be the fastest among all tested methods.
Implementation Details:
- ambi_sieve_plain: A straightforward sieve-based approach.
- rwh_primes, rwh_primes1, and rwh_primes2: Variations of Robert William Hanks' algorithms.
- sieve_wheel_30: A specialized algorithm optimized for 30-based calculations.
- sieveOfEratosthenes: The classic sieve method with bitset optimizations.
- sieveOfAtkin: A modern sieve utilizing modulo arithmetic.
- sundaram3: Sundaram's algorithm with optimizations for sets of smaller numbers.
- ambi_sieve: A sieve-based approach with NumPy optimizations.
- primesfrom3to and primesfrom2to: NumPy-based algorithms for efficiently generating primes.
Timings:
Method |
Time (ms) with Psyco |
Time (ms) without Psyco |
rwh_primes1 |
43.0 |
93.7 |
sieveOfAtkin |
46.4 |
314.0 |
rwh_primes |
57.4 |
94.6 |
sieve_wheel_30 |
63.0 |
97.4 |
rwh_primes2 |
67.8 |
68.1 |
sieveOfEratosthenes |
147.0 |
178.0 |
ambi_sieve_plain |
152.0 |
286.0 |
sundaram3 |
194.0 |
416.0 |
primesfrom2to |
Method |
Time (ms) with Psyco |
Time (ms) without Psyco |
rwh_primes1 |
43.0 |
93.7 |
sieveOfAtkin |
46.4 |
314.0 |
rwh_primes |
57.4 |
94.6 |
sieve_wheel_30 |
63.0 |
97.4 |
rwh_primes2 |
67.8 |
68.1 |
sieveOfEratosthenes |
147.0 |
178.0 |
ambi_sieve_plain |
152.0 |
286.0 |
sundaram3 |
194.0 |
416.0 |
primesfrom2to |
15.9 |
N/A |
primesfrom3to |
18.4 |
N/A |
ambi_sieve |
29.3 |
N/A |
15.9 |
N/A |
primesfrom3to |
18.4 |
N/A |
ambi_sieve |
29.3 |
N/A |
The above is the detailed content of What's the Fastest Algorithm to Generate All Prime Numbers Below a Given Integer N?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!