Why Does Implicit Type Conversion Fail in Template Argument Deduction?

Implicit Type Conversion and Template Deduction

In C , template argument deduction is a mechanism that allows type parameters to be automatically inferred based on the function arguments. However, there are limitations to implicit type conversion in template deduction.

Consider the following code snippet:

<code class="cpp">#include<iostream>
using namespace std;

template<typename Dtype>
class Scalar{
public:
  Scalar(Dtype v) : value_(v){}
private:
  Dtype value_;
};

template<typename Dtype>
void func(int a, Scalar<Dtype> b){ 
  cout << "ok" <<endl;
}

int main(){
  int a = 1;
  func(a, 2); // error: no matching function for call to ‘func(int&, int)’
  return 0;
}

Here, the goal is to call the func() template function with an integer a and an implicitly converted Scalar object 2. However, this results in a compilation error. Why is this?

Understanding the Error

The compiler fails to perform template argument deduction because:

• Implicit type conversion is not considered during template argument deduction.
• The conversion from int to Scalar is a user-defined conversion, which is not recognized by the compiler during deduction.

Solution Options

To resolve this issue, several approaches can be taken:

• Explicit Conversion at Caller Site:
  Convert the argument manually at the caller site:

  <code class="cpp">func(a, Scalar<int>{2});</code>

  Copy after login

• Deduction Guide (C 17 ):
  Define a deduction guide for Scalar and call func() as:

  <code class="cpp">func(a, Scalar{2});</code>

  Copy after login

• Explicit Template Instantiation (Only if Scalar Constructor is not Explicit):
  Explicitly instantiate the func() template for the desired type parameter:

  <code class="cpp">func<int>(a, 2); </code>

  Copy after login

Conclusion

Template argument deduction in C is a powerful mechanism, but it has limitations when dealing with user-defined conversions. By utilizing the discussed solutions, developers can ensure that template functions are called with the intended type parameters.

The above is the detailed content of Why Does Implicit Type Conversion Fail in Template Argument Deduction?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!