Backend Development
C++
Why Does `static_assert` Behavior Vary Between GCC and Clang When Dependent on a Non-Type Template Parameter?
Why Does `static_assert` Behavior Vary Between GCC and Clang When Dependent on a Non-Type Template Parameter?

static_assert Dependent on Non-Type Template Parameter: Varying Behavior in GCC and Clang
In C , the static_assert macro is used to verify compile-time conditions. When the condition fails, the program is terminated with an error message.
Consider the following code:
<code class="cpp">template <int answer> struct Hitchhiker {
static_assert(sizeof(answer) != sizeof(answer), "Invalid answer");
};
template <> struct Hitchhiker<42> {};</code>This code attempts to disable general template instantiation with static_assert. However, its behavior differs between compilers:
- GCC (4.9.2): Throws an assert error only when instantiating Hitchhiker with a parameter other than 42.
- Clang (3.50): Throws the error even when the template is not instantiated.
The Standard's Perspective
The C standard dictates that a template is ill-formed if no valid specialization can be generated and it is not instantiated. In this case, there is no valid specialization for the Hitchhiker template, so it is technically ill-formed.
However, the standard does not require a diagnostic to be issued in such cases.
Compiler Implementations
GCC chooses to adhere to the standard strictly, issuing no diagnostic when the template is not instantiated (because it is already ill-formed).
Clang, on the other hand, provides a more user-friendly experience by issuing a diagnostic even when the template is not instantiated. This helps developers identify potential issues earlier in the compilation process.
Best Practice
To avoid this discrepancy, it is recommended to explicitly specialize the template for the desired parameter value instead of using static_assert to disable general template instantiation. This approach ensures consistent behavior across compilers.
For example:
<code class="cpp">template <int> struct Hitchhiker;
template <> struct Hitchhiker<42> {};</code>The above is the detailed content of Why Does `static_assert` Behavior Vary Between GCC and Clang When Dependent on a Non-Type Template Parameter?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!
Hot AI Tools
Undresser.AI Undress
AI-powered app for creating realistic nude photos
AI Clothes Remover
Online AI tool for removing clothes from photos.
Undress AI Tool
Undress images for free
Clothoff.io
AI clothes remover
AI Hentai Generator
Generate AI Hentai for free.
Hot Article
Hot Tools
Notepad++7.3.1
Easy-to-use and free code editor
SublimeText3 Chinese version
Chinese version, very easy to use
Zend Studio 13.0.1
Powerful PHP integrated development environment
Dreamweaver CS6
Visual web development tools
SublimeText3 Mac version
God-level code editing software (SublimeText3)
Hot Topics
1378
52
C language data structure: data representation and operation of trees and graphs
Apr 04, 2025 am 11:18 AM
C language data structure: The data representation of the tree and graph is a hierarchical data structure consisting of nodes. Each node contains a data element and a pointer to its child nodes. The binary tree is a special type of tree. Each node has at most two child nodes. The data represents structTreeNode{intdata;structTreeNode*left;structTreeNode*right;}; Operation creates a tree traversal tree (predecision, in-order, and later order) search tree insertion node deletes node graph is a collection of data structures, where elements are vertices, and they can be connected together through edges with right or unrighted data representing neighbors.
The truth behind the C language file operation problem
Apr 04, 2025 am 11:24 AM
The truth about file operation problems: file opening failed: insufficient permissions, wrong paths, and file occupied. Data writing failed: the buffer is full, the file is not writable, and the disk space is insufficient. Other FAQs: slow file traversal, incorrect text file encoding, and binary file reading errors.
How do I use rvalue references effectively in C ?
Mar 18, 2025 pm 03:29 PM
Article discusses effective use of rvalue references in C for move semantics, perfect forwarding, and resource management, highlighting best practices and performance improvements.(159 characters)
How do I use ranges in C 20 for more expressive data manipulation?
Mar 17, 2025 pm 12:58 PM
C 20 ranges enhance data manipulation with expressiveness, composability, and efficiency. They simplify complex transformations and integrate into existing codebases for better performance and maintainability.
What are the basic requirements for c language functions
Apr 03, 2025 pm 10:06 PM
C language functions are the basis for code modularization and program building. They consist of declarations (function headers) and definitions (function bodies). C language uses values to pass parameters by default, but external variables can also be modified using address pass. Functions can have or have no return value, and the return value type must be consistent with the declaration. Function naming should be clear and easy to understand, using camel or underscore nomenclature. Follow the single responsibility principle and keep the function simplicity to improve maintainability and readability.
How to calculate c-subscript 3 subscript 5 c-subscript 3 subscript 5 algorithm tutorial
Apr 03, 2025 pm 10:33 PM
The calculation of C35 is essentially combinatorial mathematics, representing the number of combinations selected from 3 of 5 elements. The calculation formula is C53 = 5! / (3! * 2!), which can be directly calculated by loops to improve efficiency and avoid overflow. In addition, understanding the nature of combinations and mastering efficient calculation methods is crucial to solving many problems in the fields of probability statistics, cryptography, algorithm design, etc.
How does dynamic dispatch work in C and how does it affect performance?
Mar 17, 2025 pm 01:08 PM
The article discusses dynamic dispatch in C , its performance costs, and optimization strategies. It highlights scenarios where dynamic dispatch impacts performance and compares it with static dispatch, emphasizing trade-offs between performance and
How do I use move semantics in C to improve performance?
Mar 18, 2025 pm 03:27 PM
The article discusses using move semantics in C to enhance performance by avoiding unnecessary copying. It covers implementing move constructors and assignment operators, using std::move, and identifies key scenarios and pitfalls for effective appl


